Story 1 of 5
Canada’s economy stalled again in August and September points to a decline, two days after the Bank of Canada raised rates

01What happened
Statistics Canada reported this morning that real GDP was essentially unchanged in August, the second flat month in a row and below the 0.2% gain economists expected. Goods-producing industries edged up 0.1% while services slipped 0.1%, and nine of 20 sectors grew. Retail trade rose 1.2% on motor vehicle sales and manufacturing added 0.3%, but wholesale trade fell 1.4% as most of its subsectors contracted, the public sector fell 0.2% as census work wound down, oil and gas extraction fell 1.2% for a third month and utilities fell 0.4% on nuclear maintenance outages. The agency’s advance estimate has GDP down 0.1% in September, with losses in manufacturing and in mining, quarrying and oil and gas, and a third-quarter gain of about 0.3% before annualizing, which works out to roughly 1.2% at an annual rate, our arithmetic. The Bank of Canada’s forecast on Wednesday assumed about 2% for the quarter.
Thursday’s payroll figures point the same way. Payroll employment fell 49,600, or 0.3%, in August after a 15,700 drop in July, with declines in 10 of 20 sectors, led by federal public administration (down 15,900, or 4.1%, as temporary Census staffing ended), accommodation and food services (down 6,800) and construction (down 4,500). Average weekly earnings were $1,355, up 3.7% from a year earlier, and job vacancies held at 507,200 with a vacancy rate of 2.8%, unchanged since December. Government of Canada bond yieldsBond yield The annual return an investor gets for lending to a government or company through a bond. Yields rise when bond prices fall. Fixed mortgage rates are priced from the 5-year Government of Canada yield. rose on the day of the hike: the Bank’s published closes for Wednesday 28 October have the two-year at 3.41%, the five-year at 3.62% and the ten-year at 3.87%, each up 4 or 5 basis points. The bond market’s reaction to this morning’s data comes after this Brief was filed.
02Our view
Today’s data pulls the Bank of Canada’s second hike toward January rather than December, and lowers the likely ceiling for this cycle to 2.75%. We still expect one more quarter point, but not at the December decision unless the October figures surprise.
Why we think so. The Bank raised rates on Wednesday to stop energy costs spreading into other prices, not because growth was strong, so weak growth on its own will not reverse the move. But the Bank also said it would proceed carefully, and the data give it every reason to. Real GDP was essentially unchanged in August, the second flat month in a row and below the 0.2% gain expected. Services slipped 0.1%, wholesale trade fell 1.4%, oil and gas extraction fell 1.2% for a third month, and only nine of 20 sectors grew. The advance estimate has GDP down 0.1% in September, which puts third-quarter growth near 1.2% at an annual rate against the roughly 2% the Bank assumed in its forecast two days ago. Payrolls tell the same story: employment fell 49,600 in August after a 15,700 drop in July, with declines in 10 of 20 sectors. A central bank that hiked for inflation reasons can tolerate one soft month; it is harder to justify a second move into an economy that is flat and shedding jobs.
What the market is pricing. Markets had a December move near a coin flip before this release. Bond yields rose on the day of the hike, with the two-year at 3.41%, the five-year at 3.62% and the ten-year at 3.87%, each up 4 or 5 basis points. Our view is that the coin flip should now lean toward a December hold. Not every signal is weak: average weekly earnings were up 3.7% from a year earlier and job vacancies held at 507,200, which is why we keep a second hike in the outlook rather than calling the cycle over.
What it means. For variable-rate borrowers, the prime rate has probably taken most of the increase it will see this year. Anyone choosing between fixed and variable at an autumn renewal can reasonably price the variable option on the assumption of one more quarter point rather than three, and compare that with the fixed quote; the gap between the two paths is narrower than it looked on Wednesday. Households whose income depends on a cyclical employer, such as construction, restaurants or the federal public service, face a softer job market at the same time as a higher prime rate, which argues for a larger cash buffer. Business owners should read flat wholesale and falling manufacturing as a demand signal for the months ahead.
What would change our mind. A clear rebound in hiring in the October Labour Force Survey in early November, together with October CPI in mid-November showing inflation excluding gasoline above 2.5%, would put a December hike back as the base case. A revision of September GDP to a gain on 30 November would also weaken our view.
What to watch. The October Labour Force Survey on Friday 6 November. October CPI in mid-November, with inflation excluding gasoline the measure that matters. The full September GDP figure on 30 November.
03Why it matters to you
If your family relies on your income and you carry a variable mortgage, now is the time to know how long you could keep paying if that income stopped.
Sources The Canadian Press, Economic growth stalled again in August, StatCan says; investingLive, Canada GDP for August 0.0% vs 0.2% estimate; Finimize, Canada’s Economy Flatlined Again In August; Statistics Canada, Payroll employment, earnings and hours, and job vacancies, August 2026; Bank of Canada, Selected bond yields



